The authors of lacan deleuze badiou mainly take this approach in their book by. Yet as deleuze remarks, there is a crucial experience of. This investigation into political appearance of subjects through concepts of law, body and life is led and influenced by the thought of gilles deleuze and jacques lacan, as well as alain badiou, antonio negri and slavoj zizek. This debate not only offers the occasion to find an entrance to deleuze s basic thought, but. Badiou is neither a poststructuralist nor an analytic philosopher, and for one major reason. Zizek reads in deleuzes corpus two different ontologies, one engaged with in his solo work and the other in his collaborations with guattari. This equation is borrowed from deleuze and guattari 1994, pp. All quotes and facts are derived from the deleuze and guattari biography intersecting lives, unless otherwise. Herein emerges the principal difference between lacan and badiou. For anyone whos carefully followed deleuze s arguments about the logic of representation its clear that this should immediately make ones ears perk up as it suggests an opposition. The event in deleuze alain badiou translated by jon roffe1 deleuze always paid tribute to sartre as the. In this revised edition, there are expanded entries on architecture, cinema and psychoanalysis key areas where interest in deleuze has. Deleuze, marx and politics a critical and provocative exploration of the political, conceptual and cultural points of resonance between deleuzes minor politics and marxs critique of capitalist dynamics, deleuze, marx and politics is the first book to engage with deleuzes missing work, the grandeur of marx.
This book can be seen as a guide to reading deleuze, but at the same time it is a direct confrontation with issues at stake, particularly the debate with and against psychoanalysis. For those who view deleuze as the apostle of desire, flux, and multiplicity, badious book is a deliberate provocation. Deleuze deploys the onesubstance as the indifferent medium of multitude. Lacan claims that guilt occupies the field of desire, there is a permanent bookkeeping or debt to be paid via guilt in the subject not giving up on his desire. Badious text has generated many important controversies and bones of contention. Deleuze reacted calmly, pretending to agree with them and retaliating with irony. This latter point lies behind much of the difference between badiou. While the combined corpus of these three figures contains a significant number of references to each others work, such references are often simply critical, obscure or both. Ok, im exaggerating a bit, but the point is that lacan has been popularized and updated in a very big way. Apr 17, 2015 in previous columns, i have explored the ontology, theory of the state, theory of the event, and political views of alain badiou. In the englishlanguage reception of alain badious work, he has often been onesidedly positioned as a direct heir to the antihumanist projects of lacan, althusser and foucault. His critique of representational thinking does not allow notions such as opposition contradiction, negation, and so on. The firstthe proper lacanian positionpresents the event as an.
Jul 02, 20 deleuze reacted calmly, pretending to agree with them and retaliating with irony. When ive read deleuze and guattaris work 24 years ago i wanted desperatly to become a deleuzian. Through a deep philosophical engagement with his writings, badiou contends that deleuze is not the dionysian thinker of becoming he took himself to be. Despite deleuze s initial worries about lacan s reaction to antioedipus, lacan obviously did not dismiss the book. Derrida inverts it into the radical otherness which differs from itself. He considered the 1937 article, the transcendence of the ego, the origin of everything. Deleuze and the lacanian real jacques lacanlacan dot com. Readers will thrill to its edginess, intuitions, learning and irreverence. Access article in pdf the inverse side of the structure.
A reconfiguration of the reception of deleuze and lacan in contemporary continental philosophy. An ethics beyond the impasse of desire and enjoyment 2 this tend in. It would be easy to be thrown, though, hurt and bemused by a wild swirl of ideas. In an interview in 1995, shortly before his death, gilles deleuze was asked by french scholar didier eribon about his relationship with jacques. In this final essay, i compare and contrast badious work with one of my favourite theorists, and badious bete noire. The book rather seems to be a collection of essays that sometimes encounter the thought of deleuze, but other thinkers as well such as alain badiou. These readers will find abstracts of selected concepts, directed exposition, and putatively helpful comparative discussion of these concepts as they range across the three authors. Pdf jean jacques lecercle, badiou and deleuze read. Lacan conceives it as a challenge to be taken up and, as often, in a paradoxical way. Taking up deleuzes own image, zizek claims that he is engaging in a kind of hegelian. Pdf jeanjacques lecercle, badiou and deleuze read literature. In deleuze, life is still the answer to why is there something and not nothing. This raises the serious problem of defining the specific difference between althussers llnderstanding of the relation of philosophy to ideology and badious owu concept of.
This raises the serious problem of defining the specific difference between althussers llnderstanding of the relation of philosophy to ideology and badiou s owu concept of philosophy. Lacan deleuze badiou guides us through these crucial, underremarked interrelations, identifying the conceptual passages, connections and disjunctions that underlie the often superficial statements of critique, indifference or agreement. Badiou has written about the concepts of being, truth and the subject in a way that, he claims, is neither postmodern nor simply a repetition of. However, if one expects this to be an indepth commentary or critique on deleuzian thought, prepare to be disappointed. This wager into 23 badiou develops a neologism of splace to combine the. Badiou, following both lacan and heidegger, distances truth from knowledge. The clamor of being presents deleuze as an aristocratic philosopher of the one, a nietzschean vitalist who isnt too far removed from platos parmenidies in continually affirming that there is only one path to being. Organs without bodies was an interesting and even entertaining read. Subjectivization, in a nod to lacan, is the name badiou gives for what. This is a fierce ride through the tangled relations of lacan, deleuze and badiou. For anyone whos carefully followed deleuzes arguments about the logic of representation its clear that this should immediately make ones ears perk up as it suggests an opposition. Deleuzes updaters have not yet gained that mainstream foothold in the way someone like zizek or badiou has. Project muse the inverse side of the structure zizek on.
Deleuzes philosophy and explains the main intellectual influences on deleuze as well as the influence deleuze has had on subjects such as feminism, cinema, postcolonial theory, geography and cultural studies. Deleuzes move here as an opportunity to neatly couple him with lacan, noting triumphantly that the deleuzian quasicause parallels the lacanian objet petit a, the pure, immaterial, spectral entity that serves as the objectcause of desire owb, 27a point deleuze and guattari themselves acknowledge in. It is often said that lacan is the most radical representative of structuralism, a thinker of negativity and alienation, whereas deleuze is pictured as a great opponent of the structuralist project, a vitalist and a thinker of creative potentialities of desire. The point is not so much to play spinoza and kant against each other.
Januar 1937 in rabat ist ein franzosischer, marxistisch bzw. The theoretical writings of jacques lacan, gilles deleuze and alain badiou stand at the heart of contemporary acknowledgements jacques lacan and gilles deleuze are probably two of the badiou and the future of philosophy london and new york. Inspect it warily, before mounting only if it suits. Badiou begins my reminding us that the relationship of art and philosophy has always been that of an oscillation, a back and forth, a neverending loop he describes art as the key to education and speaks of lacans theory of the master and the hysteric as a relation parallel to that of philosophy and art. Bell southeastern louisiana university of the important french philosophers of the latter half of the twentieth century, gilles deleuze stands unquestionably as one of the most influential. Pdf lacan, deleuze, and the consequences of formalism. The first volume contained deleuzes essay, while the second volume consisted exclusively of fullpage reproductions of bacons. But the resemblance to badiou is stylistic as well as substantive, since one finds a similar strategy of avoidance and displacement in zizeks booka lacanian book on deleuze that does not contain a single discussion of deleuzes reading of lacan. Oct 24, 2003 organs without bodies was an interesting and even entertaining read. Or, how to beat your death drive a lecture by aron dunlap duration. Different positions in contemporary philosophy lacan, badiou, deleuze can be read in terms of the psychoanalytic menage a trois of desire, love, and enjoymenta philosophical clinic. Between the two models, there is a lacanian subjectivation that badiou. The first volume contained deleuze s essay, while the second volume consisted exclusively of fullpage reproductions of bacons. Although lacan s act and badiou s event both involve a subject, the badiousian subject is dialectically intertwined with the truth.
In the latter half of the 20th century, lacan and badiou are virtually alone in their. Combining sartre with lacan, guattari finds that such groups are at once subjects. Deleuze s updaters have not yet gained that mainstream foothold in the way someone like zizek or badiou has. Jacquesalain miller once characterized this reading with the same words as deleuze. Badiou does a masterly job here of fleshing out the ontological side of deleuzian theory, delving especially into the latters doctoral work and possibly one of his most difficult works on difference as such difference and repetition as vastly grander than simply the domain of the accidental to which aristotle relegated itpropounding a thesis that deleuze himself in fact corroborates. For deleuze this is like saying negation is the centre of becoming since the whole project of plateaus is to create a concept of desire as the productive force of life. In previous columns, i have explored the ontology, theory of the state, theory of the event, and political views of alain badiou. Deleuzes move here as an opportunity to neatly couple him with lacan, noting triumphantly that the deleuzian quasicause parallels the lacanian objet petit a, the pure, immaterial, spectral entity that serves as the objectcause of desire owb, 27a point deleuze and guattari themselves acknowledge in antioedipus. Between lacan and badiou tspace university of toronto.
This contrasts with the lacan pole which puts lack at the centre of desire. This compact critical volume is not only a powerful reappraisal of deleuzes thought. The firstthe proper lacanian positionpresents the event as. One of the constants of the deleuzian secondary literature is the opposition between the work of deleuze and guattari and the work of lacan. Lacan explicitly and repeatedly declared his allegiance to freud. Thus, badiou in his seminar is able to interrogate lacan from the point of view of a. Continuum, of desire for lacan and the fidelity to an eventor truthprocessfor badiou. Lacan is deeply absorbed by the borromean knot theory and by the preparation of the part on joyce in his seminar, the first lesson of which he will give on november 18th, 1975. The clamor of being alain badiou, louise burchill on. He considered the 1937 article, the transcendence of the. We have written this book for four groups of people. May 22, 2006 one of the constants of the deleuzian secondary literature is the opposition between the work of deleuze and guattari and the work of lacan. The main object of this paper is to examine the new philosophical frame proposed by alain badiou and slavoj zizek and to show that it implies some traces of sartres philosophical and political. The result is neither a lacanian reading of deleuze nor a deleuzian reading of lacan but rather a systematic and comparative analysis that identifies concerns common to both thinkers and their ultimately incompatible ways of addressing them.
On the contrary, not only was his reading of the book the apparent basis of his summons to deleuze, but he even seems to have been influenced by antioedipus in his own thinking. Only once did deleuze get angry, when he found on his desk a tract by a death squad advocating suicide. Adam bartlett, justin clemens and jon roffe, lacan deleuze badiou eup. The works of gilles deleuze on cinema, literature, painting, and philosophy have made him one of the most widely read thinkers of his generation. In the trouble with pleasure, aaron schuster tackles this tangled relationship head on.
Lacan, deleuze and world politics rethinking the ontology of the political subject, 1st edition. His most popular works were the two volumes of capitalism and schizophrenia. Pdf some notes with badiou and zizek on eventtruth. The first are those new to the work of alain badiou, gilles deleuze and jacques lacan. Consequently, it would be unjust to state that deleuze opposes himself to psychoanalysis for the sake of. But ive been cautious enough to read all freuds work and lacans among others like foucaults. They are the ones whom badiou, in an open homage to gilles deleuzes. This question is foreign to both poststructuralism and analytic philosophy in fact not only foreign, but unwelcome.
1313 1382 1522 909 520 361 1326 1172 16 725 962 796 1424 85 247 350 1408 707 663 1350 818 823 138 497 1182 831 1404 1475